FPLPlayer Comparison

Harvey Barnes vs John McGinn: Who should I pick for Fantasy Premier League Gameweek 8?

MID · Gameweek 8 Fantasy Premier League Head-to-Head Comparison

Barnes
MIDNewcastle

Barnes

Newcastle

32

Pts

2.0

Form

£6.1m

Price

VS

GW8

McGinn
MIDAston Villa

McGinn

Aston Villa

28

Pts

5.5

Form

£5.4m

Price

No credit card required
Instant access

Harvey Barnes vs John McGinn: Gameweek 8 Analysis

PhotoPlayerGW xPtsFormSeason PtsGoalsAssistsPts per £mOwnershipPrice
Barnes

Barnes

MID - Newcastle

22.032135.27.7%£6.1m
McGinn

McGinn

MID - Aston Villa

5.55.528125.22.8%£5.4m
SLIGHT EDGE: MCGINN

John McGinn holds a slight edge over Harvey Barnes heading into Gameweek 8, driven by higher expected points.

  • John McGinn projects 3.5 more expected points in GW8.
  • John McGinn is in sharper form with 5.5 points per game over the last six gameweeks.
  • Harvey Barnes faces an easier GW8 opponent (FDR 3 vs 4).

Fixture run - next 4 gameweeks

Barnes

Barnes

GW8

Crystal Palace

Crystal Palace

Away

GW9

Everton

Everton

Home

GW10

Fulham

Fulham

Away

GW11

Arsenal

Arsenal

Home

McGinn

McGinn

GW8

Man City

Man City

Home

GW9

Fulham

Fulham

Home

GW10

Man Utd

Man Utd

Away

GW11

Sunderland

Sunderland

Home

The case for each player

Barnes

  • Harvey Barnes has registered 1 goal and 3 assists this season, totalling 32 points at £6.1m.
  • Expected to score 2.0 points in GW8, making Barnes a viable starting option.
  • With only 7.7% ownership, Barnes offers differential value to boost your rank if they deliver.

McGinn

  • John McGinn has registered 1 goal and 2 assists this season, totalling 28 points at £5.4m.
  • Expected to score 5.5 points in GW8, making McGinn a viable starting option.
  • With only 2.8% ownership, McGinn offers differential value to boost your rank if they deliver.

Barnes vs McGinn Gameweek 8

Click a question below and get the full breakdown.

CF
I've pulled the latest GW8 data for Harvey Barnes and John McGinn. The verdict is below - click any question for more detail.

Ask a question

ChatFPL AI

McGinn has the better fixture and the lower price tag - saving you £0.7m.

Ask ChatFPL AI where that saving should go in your specific squad.

Try ChatFPL AI Free