FPLPlayer Comparison

Nathan Collins vs James Tarkowski: Who should I pick for Fantasy Premier League Gameweek 2?

DEF · Gameweek 2 Fantasy Premier League Head-to-Head Comparison

Collins
DEFBrentford

Collins

Brentford

6

Pts

6.0

Form

£5.5m

Price

VS

GW2

Tarkowski
DEFEverton

Tarkowski

Everton

6

Pts

6.0

Form

£6.0m

Price

No credit card required
Instant access

Nathan Collins vs James Tarkowski: Gameweek 2 Analysis

PhotoPlayerGW xPtsFormSeason PtsGoalsAssistsPts per £mOwnershipPrice
Collins

Collins

DEF - Brentford

2.56.06001.12%£5.5m
Tarkowski

Tarkowski

DEF - Everton

2.86.060018.8%£6.0m
TOO CLOSE TO CALL

Nathan Collins and James Tarkowski are closely matched in Gameweek 2. Both carry similar expected returns, form, and fixture difficulty. This one comes down to your squad needs and risk tolerance.

  • James Tarkowski projects 0.3 more expected points in GW2.

Fixture run - next 4 gameweeks

Collins

Collins

GW2

Leeds

Leeds

Away

GW3

Sunderland

Sunderland

Home

GW4

Bournemouth

Bournemouth

Away

GW5

Chelsea

Chelsea

Home

Tarkowski

Tarkowski

GW2

Bournemouth

Bournemouth

Away

GW3

Man Utd

Man Utd

Home

GW4

Spurs

Spurs

Away

GW5

Ipswich Town

Ipswich Town

Home

The case for each player

Collins

  • Nathan Collins has registered 0 goals and 0 assists this season, totalling 6 points at £5.5m.
  • Expected to score 2.5 points in GW2, making Collins a viable starting option.
  • With only 2% ownership, Collins offers differential value to boost your rank if they deliver.

Tarkowski

  • James Tarkowski has registered 0 goals and 0 assists this season, totalling 6 points at £6.0m.
  • Expected to score 2.8 points in GW2, making Tarkowski a viable starting option.
  • With only 8.8% ownership, Tarkowski offers differential value to boost your rank if they deliver.

Collins vs Tarkowski Gameweek 2

Click a question below and get the full breakdown.

CF
I've pulled the latest GW2 data for Nathan Collins and James Tarkowski. The verdict is below - click any question for more detail.

Ask a question

ChatFPL AI

Tarkowski has the better fixture run - but Collins frees up £0.5m.

Ask ChatFPL AI how to spend that £0.5m saving on your specific squad.

Try ChatFPL AI for free