Question 1

Who has the stronger DEFCON rate: Silva or Thomas?

Accepted Answer

Barely anything in it. Silva averages 11.20 defensive contribution actions per 90 and Thomas averages 10.71 - a gap of 0.49 that is inside the natural noise of any per-90 metric. On the workload alone this is a coin toss and the decision should rest on fixture, price and attacking output rather than DEFCON.

Question 2

How do the raw defensive workloads of Silva and Thomas compare?

Accepted Answer

Silva has logged 56 combined clearances, blocks, interceptions and tackles across 450 minutes (11.2 per 90). Thomas has logged 52 across 437 minutes (10.7 per 90). Silva earned the +2pt DEFCON bonus in 4 of 5 appearances this season; Thomas earned the +2pt DEFCON bonus in 3 of 5 appearances this season. Higher raw counts reflect a higher defensive workload; higher per-90 rates reflect efficiency at sustaining that workload.

Question 3

Does the Gameweek 6 fixture change the DEFCON case?

Accepted Answer

Silva is away at Chelsea (FDR 4) and Thomas is at home to Newcastle (FDR 2) in Gameweek 6. DEFCON output is action-based rather than result-based, so a tough fixture does not shrink the base rate the way it might reduce a clean sheet probability. That said, both players are more likely to see defensive volume in tougher matches - the DEFCON case can actually be marginally stronger against stronger opposition.

Question 4

Which defender should I pick for Gameweek 6 on DEFCON grounds?

Accepted Answer

The DEFCON workloads are too close to call. Both Silva and Thomas deliver similar defensive contribution rates, so the pick should come down to price, fixtures and attacking output rather than DEFCON. On the defensive contributions alone this is a genuine coin toss.

Silva vs Bobby Thomas DEFCON: Fantasy Premier League Gameweek 6

Silva vs Bobby Thomas: DEFCON Analysis

Silva vs Thomas Gameweek 6

Silva has the DEFCON edge but costs £1.0m more than Thomas. Where should the money go?